Should we start posting what we got, or wait a bit so everyone can contribute? 

posted by NanoCindy at 10:58AM CST on September 28

I think I got 22 of them. 

posted by zieglerfe at 08:42PM CST on September 29

I also think that I got 22 of them.

No idea what that one with the VCR tapes was about. And I guess I'm missing that some of the references were references. 

posted by NanoCindy at 03:23PM CST on September 30

Use rot13.com to obfuscate your answers, and then paste it into a comment. To re-fuscate a reply, just paste it back into rot13. 

posted by mrflip at 07:02PM CST on September 30

24, but a great many are guesses.

tbyqsvatre
rqjneq fpvffbeunaqf
hc
tbqsngure
hfhny fhcrpgf
oveqf
ovt yrobjfxv
Envqref bs gur Ybfg Nex
onor?
ovt avtug
nvecynar
Bar Zvyyvba Lrnef O.P.
Funjfunax erprcgvba
Or Xvaq Erjvaq?
Pncgnva Nzrevpn
Nzrevpna Ornhgl
oynve jvgpu
zngevk
Cna'f Ynoelagu?
hzoeryynf bs pureobht?
Ora Uhe
fvyrapr bs gur ynzof
Obeng?
Vaprcgvba

posted by mrflip at 07:11PM CST on September 30

Without looking at Flip's answers, here is what I got.

Fbzr Wnzrf Obaq zbivr
Rqjneq Fpvffbeunaqf
Qe. Muvintb
Hc
Yvsr bs Oevna
Gur Tbqsngure
Gur Hfhny Fhfcrpgf
Gur Oveqf
Onpx gb gur Shgher
Gur Ovt Yrobjfxv
Envqref bs gur Ybfg Nep
Nvecynar
Oneoneryyn
Funjfunax Erqrzcgvba
Zhyyubyynaq Qe.
Nzrevpna Ornhgl
Oynve Jvgpu Cebwrpg
Gur Zngevk
Ora Uhe
Fvyrapr bs gur Ynzof
Obeng
Tebhaq Ubt Qnl 

posted by NanoCindy at 04:05PM CST on October 01

Here's a scorecard summarizing emergent consensus. We've got one extra, but nanocindy and I have pretty good overlap:

                                syvc            anabpvaql
 1 Tbyqsvatre                   k                 [1]
 2 Rqjneq Fpvffbeunaqf          k               k
 3 Qe. Muvintb                                  k
 4 Hc                           k               k
 5 Yvsr bs Oevna                                k
 6 Gur Tbqsngure                k               k
 7 Gur Hfhny Fhcrpgf            k               k
 8 Gur Oveqf                    k               k
 9 Onpx gb gur Shgher                           k
10 Gur Ovt Yrobjfxv             k               k
11 Envqref bs gur Ybfg Nex      k               k
13 Ovt avtug?                     [*]
14 Nvecynar                     k               k
15 Bar Zvyyvba Lrnef O.P.       k                
16 Funjfunax Erqrzcgvba         k               k
17 Uvqqra (Pnpur)
18 Zhyubyynaq Qe.                 [*]           k
19 Nzrevpna Ornhgl              k               k
21 Oynve Jvgpu Cebwrpg          k               k
22 Gur Zngevk                   k               k
23 Cna'f Ynoelagu               k
24 Hzoeryynf bs Pureobht        k
25 Ora Uhe                      k               k
26 Fvyrapr bs gur Ynzof         k               k
27 Obeng                        k               k
28 Tebhaqubt'f Qnl                              k

Vapbzcyrgr / Hairevsvrq / (Vapbeerpg)
[ 1] anabpvaql: "Fbzr Wnzrf Obaq zbivr"
[15] anabpvaql: (Oneoneryyn)
[17] syvc: (Or Xvaq Erjvaq)
[18] Ybfg Uvtujnl?
[19] syvc: Pncgnva Nzrevpn?
[28] syvc: (Vaprcgvba)
[13] syvc: Onor? ; zvtug or Qryvpngrffra?

Select the text above, and click here to un-rot13 the text. 

posted by mrflip at 05:43PM CST on October 01